Blue Buffalo vs Wellness CORE: Which Premium Dog Food Is Better?

Two of the most popular premium dog food brands sit side by side on pet store shelves, both promising superior nutrition for your dog. Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula and Wellness CORE Grain-Free Original are both positioned as premium alternatives to grocery store brands. But they take fundamentally different approaches to canine nutrition.

After conducting a 90-day side-by-side feeding trial with 8 dogs and analyzing every aspect of both formulas, we have a clear verdict. Here is our comprehensive comparison. For individual deep dives, read our full Blue Buffalo Life Protection review and our Wellness CORE Grain-Free review. And for background on what makes a quality dog food, see our how to choose dog food guide.

Barking Goods is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

At a Glance: Blue Buffalo vs. Wellness CORE

Protein Content: Wellness CORE Wins Decisively

The most significant difference between these two foods is protein content. Wellness CORE delivers 34% minimum crude protein compared to Blue Buffalo’s 24%.

Why Protein Matters

Dogs are facultative carnivores — they thrive on meat-based protein as the foundation of their diet. While 24% protein meets AAFCO minimums for adult maintenance, many canine nutritionists consider 28-38% more appropriate for active adult dogs.

Wellness CORE’s 34% protein comes primarily from deboned turkey and turkey meal, supplemented with chicken meal. The high animal protein content provides a complete amino acid profile that supports muscle maintenance, immune function, and overall health.

Blue Buffalo’s 24% protein comes from deboned chicken, chicken meal, and brown rice. While the chicken protein is high quality, the inclusion of grains as carbohydrate sources means protein represents a smaller percentage of the overall formula.

Real-World Difference

In our 90-day feeding trial, we did not observe dramatic differences in energy levels or muscle condition between the two groups. Both foods provided adequate protein for the dogs in our panel. However, the higher protein content of Wellness CORE means you are getting more of the most expensive and nutritionally dense component per dollar, which represents better value from a pure nutrition standpoint.

Verdict: Wellness CORE wins. 34% protein from animal sources is a superior protein profile for most adult dogs.

Ingredient Quality: Both Strong, CORE Slightly Better

Both brands position themselves as premium alternatives to budget dog foods, and both deliver on that promise — though with different approaches.

Blue Buffalo Life Protection

Blue Buffalo’s ingredient list is designed to be readable and recognizable. The first five ingredients are deboned chicken, chicken meal, brown rice, oatmeal, and barley. There are no by-product meals, no corn, wheat, or soy, and no artificial preservatives.

Blue Buffalo’s signature feature is their LifeSource Bits — small, cold-formed kibble pieces mixed into the regular kibble that contain a concentrated blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals. The cold-forming process is designed to preserve the potency of these nutrients.

Wellness CORE Grain-Free

Wellness CORE’s first five ingredients are deboned turkey, turkey meal, chicken meal, peas, and potatoes. Like Blue Buffalo, there are no by-product meals and no artificial additives. The grain-free approach means plant-based carbohydrates come from peas and potatoes rather than whole grains.

What sets Wellness CORE apart is the supplement profile. In addition to standard vitamins and minerals, the formula includes:

• Four strains of probiotics (added after the cooking process for viability)
• Glucosamine AND chondroitin for joint support
• Taurine for heart health (a particularly thoughtful addition given the grain-free DCM discussion)
• Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids from both flaxseed and salmon oil
• Antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables (spinach, broccoli, carrots, blueberries, apples)

Blue Buffalo’s supplement profile is more basic: glucosamine (no chondroitin), LifeSource Bits with antioxidants, and some omega fatty acids.

Verdict: Wellness CORE has a slight edge. Both use quality primary ingredients, but CORE’s supplement package is significantly more comprehensive.

The Grain-Free Question: Blue Buffalo’s Advantage

This is where the comparison gets nuanced and where Blue Buffalo has a meaningful advantage in the current nutritional landscape.

The FDA Investigation

Since 2018, the FDA has been investigating a potential link between grain-free diets (particularly those heavy in legumes like peas and lentils) and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs. DCM is a serious heart condition that can be fatal.

As of 2026, the investigation has not established a definitive causal link, and no grain-free foods have been recalled as a result. However, the veterinary community has generally shifted toward recommending grain-inclusive diets as a precaution, especially for breeds not genetically predisposed to DCM.

Blue Buffalo’s Grain-Inclusive Formula

Blue Buffalo Life Protection includes whole grains (brown rice, oatmeal, barley) as carbohydrate sources. These provide energy, fiber, and some nutritional value while avoiding the legume-heavy carbohydrate profile that the FDA investigation flagged. This aligns with the current veterinary consensus.

Wellness CORE’s Response

Wellness CORE is grain-free and does include peas as a carbohydrate source — a legume that was mentioned in the FDA investigation. However, Wellness has taken a proactive step by adding taurine to the formula. Taurine is an amino acid that is crucial for heart health, and some researchers theorize that grain-free diets may interfere with taurine metabolism. The addition of supplemental taurine is a responsible measure.

Verdict: Blue Buffalo has the advantage here. In an uncertain landscape, the grain-inclusive formula carries less nutritional controversy. If the grain-free DCM question concerns you, Blue Buffalo is the safer choice.

Palatability: Both Excellent

In our feeding trial, both foods were readily accepted by all 8 test dogs. Neither food had a palatability advantage — dogs ate both enthusiastically.

The only notable difference: some owners reported that their dogs initially picked around the Blue Buffalo LifeSource Bits, eating the regular kibble first and the dark bits last. This is a commonly reported quirk, though most dogs eventually eat them without selectivity.

Verdict: Tie. Both foods are highly palatable.

Coat and Skin Quality: Wellness CORE Wins

This is where we saw the most visible difference in our 90-day feeding trial.

Dogs fed Wellness CORE showed noticeable improvements in coat quality by day 30 — shinier, softer, and less dry. By day 60, the difference between the CORE group and the Blue Buffalo group was visible to our testers.

We attribute this to Wellness CORE’s higher concentration of omega fatty acids, particularly from salmon oil. Blue Buffalo includes some omega fatty acids but at lower levels.

Both groups showed healthy skin throughout the trial, with no itching, hot spots, or allergy symptoms.

Verdict: Wellness CORE wins. The higher omega fatty acid content delivers visible coat benefits. If your dog is one of the breeds prone to coat issues — such as a Golden Retriever or Labrador Retriever — this difference is particularly relevant.

Digestive Health: Wellness CORE Wins

Wellness CORE’s inclusion of four probiotic strains gives it a meaningful edge in digestive support. Probiotics support healthy gut bacteria, which influences everything from nutrient absorption to immune function.

In our feeding trial, both groups produced healthy, well-formed stools. The Wellness CORE group showed slightly more consistent stool quality, particularly during the transition period (days 1-7). This suggests that the probiotics may help mitigate the digestive upset that often accompanies food changes.

Blue Buffalo does not include probiotics in the Life Protection formula (though some of their specialty lines do).

Verdict: Wellness CORE wins. The probiotic inclusion is a genuine advantage.

Value for Money: Blue Buffalo Wins on Price

Blue Buffalo Life Protection typically costs $50-60 for a 30 lb bag, or approximately $1.70-$2.00 per pound. Wellness CORE typically costs $55-65 for a 24 lb bag, or approximately $2.30-$2.70 per pound.

However, the per-pound price does not tell the full story:

• Wellness CORE is more calorie-dense (421 kcal/cup vs 374 kcal/cup), meaning you feed less per meal
• The smaller serving size partially offsets the higher per-pound price
• Wellness CORE’s more comprehensive supplement profile means you may spend less on separate joint and probiotic supplements

Daily feeding cost comparison for a 50 lb dog:

• Blue Buffalo: approximately $1.80-$2.20 per day
• Wellness CORE: approximately $2.00-$2.50 per day

The difference is roughly $0.20-$0.30 per day, or $6-$9 per month. Significant for budget-conscious owners, but modest in the context of total pet care costs.

Verdict: Blue Buffalo wins on price. It is the more affordable option, particularly for larger dogs. For owners managing breeds with big appetites like Labrador Retrievers or German Shepherds, the cost difference adds up over time.

Who Should Choose Blue Buffalo Life Protection

Blue Buffalo is the better choice if:

• You prefer a grain-inclusive diet, which aligns with current veterinary recommendations
• Budget is a significant factor in your food choice
• Your dog does well on moderate protein levels (24%)
• You want a widely available brand that is stocked in most pet stores and grocery stores
• You are feeding a puppy (Blue Buffalo’s grain-inclusive puppy formula avoids the grain-free DCM question — see our best puppy food roundup)

Who Should Choose Wellness CORE Grain-Free

Wellness CORE is the better choice if:

• You want maximum protein content from animal sources
• Coat and skin health is a priority for your dog
• You value the comprehensive supplement profile (probiotics, chondroitin, taurine)
• Your dog has done well on grain-free diets in the past
• You have a large breed that benefits from glucosamine and chondroitin for joint support
• You are willing to pay a moderate premium for a more nutrient-dense formula

Our Overall Recommendation

Wellness CORE earns our overall recommendation with a 4.5/5 rating compared to Blue Buffalo’s 4.3/5. The higher protein content, more comprehensive supplement profile, and demonstrable coat quality benefits give it the edge.

However, the margin is closer than those numbers suggest. Blue Buffalo’s grain-inclusive formula is a meaningful advantage in the current nutritional landscape, and its lower price point makes it more accessible.

If the grain-free DCM question concerns you, choose Blue Buffalo. If maximum protein and comprehensive supplementation are your priorities, choose Wellness CORE. Either way, you are feeding your dog a premium food that is miles better than budget alternatives.

You Might Also Like

• Blue Buffalo Life Protection Review — Full hands-on review of Blue Buffalo
• Wellness CORE Grain-Free Review — Full 90-day feeding trial review of Wellness CORE
• How to Choose Dog Food — Complete guide to reading labels and AAFCO standards
• Best Dog Food for Puppies — Top picks for growing dogs
• Outward Hound Fun Feeder Review — Slow down fast eaters for better digestion
• Labrador Retriever Breed Guide — Nutrition for America’s hungriest breed
• Dog Grooming Tips — Good nutrition shows in coat quality

Frequently Asked Questions